If Eid falls on a Friday, Jumu’ah salat is still obligatory and has to be performed on time, whether one performs Eid salat or not. And this applies for both the Imam and the congregation.

This is the position of the Hanafi, Maliki and Shafi’ and one opinion of Hanbali School of Fiqh.

Ibn Qudamah in his book al-Mughni attributed this opinion to the majority of the Fuqhaa’ and Muslim Jurists.

Their evidence, is the default ruling of Jumu’ah salat as was derived from the ayah in surat al-Jumu’ah:

“O ye who believe! When the call is proclaimed to prayer on Friday (the Day of Assembly), hasten earnestly to the Remembrance of Allah, and leave off business: That is best for you if you knew…”62:9

The binding ruling of Jumu’ah salat was also clearly established by the many ahadith in Bukhari, Muslim and other collections of hadith, and this cannot be out ruled even if Eid falls on Friday.

Jumu’ah salat is also as obligatory as Eid salat, and performing one of them does not substitute for the other. Imam Ibn Hazam rahimahullah in his book al-Muhallaa said: “And if Eid and Falls on Friday, one should pray Eid first and then Jumu’ah. This is a must, and there is no reliable evidence to prove otherwise”. He then said: “Jumu’ah is Fard and Eid is supererogatory, and the supererogatory act does not override the Fard.”

Moreover, the scenario of Eid and Jumu’ah is similar to Eid and Dhuhr salat in any other day besides Friday. Therefore, if dhuhr is required on Eid day, then Jumu’ah which is the Fard of Friday is also required and remains obligatory.

The Hadith some scholars quotes to prove otherwise is the narration of Abi Ubaid, as reported in Muwatta’ Imam Malik, who said: I prayed Eid salat with Uthman ibn Affan one time. He first started with salat, and then delivered the khutbah in which he said: “This day you have two Eids coming in one day, so for the people who came form al-Awaali -the suburbs and outskirts of Madinah- whoever wishes to stay for Jumu’ah, let them stay. And whoever wishes to return home, they can leave. They have my permission.”

However, the scholars mentioned that this was for the people of a specific area, as for them it was not Wajib to Pray Jumu’ah in their locality and it was very hard for them to travel to come back to Madinah.

And Allah knows best

JazaakAllah khair

43 Thoughts on “Ruling of Jumu’a Salaah if Eid falls on Friday”

  • ПФР назвал возраст самого пожилого пенсионера в стране

    Самой пожилой пенсионерке России 128 лет, она проживает в Чеченской Республике.

    По данным Пенсионного фонда России, женщина родилась 1 июля 1889 года, передает RT.

    В конце марта Министерство здравоохранения сообщило о намерении увеличить среднюю продолжительность жизни россиян до 76 лет к 2024 году.

    7 мая президент России Владимир Путин поручил правительству обеспечить повышение средней продолжительности жизни в стране до 78 лет к 2024 году.

    Партнеры: У вас сложная финансовая ситуация? Срочно нужны деньги? Взять срочный займ вы можете на сайте – http://все-займы-тут.рф/срочные-займы-12-05-2018

  • Greetings! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this website?
    I’m getting tired of WordPress because I’ve
    had problems with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives for
    another platform. I would be great if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

  • I got this site from my buddy who shared with me on the topic of this website and at the moment
    this time I am browsing this web page and reading very informative articles or reviews at this place.

  • Hey there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after reading through some of the post I realized it’s new to me.

    Nonetheless, I’m definitely delighted I found it and I’ll be book-marking and checking back frequently!

  • I simply couldn’t depart your site prior to suggesting that I extremely loved the standard info a person provide on your guests?
    Is going to be again incessantly in order to check up on new posts

  • I just like the helpful information you provide to your articles.
    I’ll bookmark your blog and take a look at once more here regularly.
    I am relatively certain I will be told lots of new stuff proper right here!
    Best of luck for the following!

  • 激光是單一波段的光能 , 在同一時間發射 , 光線能量較為集中 , 能深入皮膚打擊患處之異常色素或血管 , 溫和地刺激皮膚內的骨膠原更生, 新生的骨膠原令您的膚質光澤柔嫩 , 煥然一新 , 抗老效果顯著。有效治療色斑(雀斑 , 太陽斑 , 咖啡斑 , 太田痣 , 紋身) , 血管問題 (葡萄色斑 , 微絲血管擴張) , 膚色不均 , 皮膚鬆弛 , 毛孔粗大 治療後皮膚會出現短暫的紅腫 , 要注意防曬及遵照醫生指示護理皮膚

  • 【美髮】減少掉髮真係work! 韓國專業頭皮護理品牌Dr.FORHAIR – Katerina的花俏部落格 •Beauty •Fashion •Lifestyle 【美髮】減少掉髮真係work! 韓國專業頭皮護理品牌Dr.FORHAIR, Katerina的花俏部落格 •Beauty •Fashion •Lifestyle: 【美髮】減少掉髮真係work! 韓國專業頭皮護理品牌Dr.FORHAIR, Katerina的花俏部落格 •Beauty •Fashion •Lifestyle

  • Hey there! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this site?
    I’m getting fed up of WordPress because I’ve had issues with hackers and I’m looking at options for another platform.
    I would be great if you could point me in the
    direction of a good platform.

  • Great blog you have here but I was curious about if you knew of any user discussion forums that cover the same topics talked about in this article?

    I’d really like to be a part of community where I can get feedback
    from other knowledgeable individuals that share the same interest.
    If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Appreciate
    it!

  • Оформить online займ в наши дни не составляет труда. Оформить займ реально в любое время, главное – иметь доступ к интернету. Необходимо сказать, что, если вы стремитесь взять займ, вам необходимо внимательно выбирать сервис, где вы будете брать кредит. Рекомендуем обращать интерес при выборе компании на разные факторы.

    На mega-zaimer.ru достаточно много людей получают займы. Сервис, который может выдать мгновенный онлайн займ – найти не так уж и легко. Достаточно много сервисов заставляют посетителей предоставлять различные документы, которые могут быть полезны кредитору тогда, если заемщик пропадет. Но, на портале доступны самые лучшие компании. Они выдают онлайн займы без проверок и без отказа. Именно по этой причине они невероятно ценятся, а сервис их предлагает.

    Некоторые фирмы предоставляют online кредиты на карту. Вы можете сделать выбор, на какую карту вы стремитесь получить ссуду. Большинство компаний выдают займы на debit cards. Некоторые фирмы выдают средства даже на виртуальные кошельки. Часть из сервисов, которые представлены на mega-zaimer.ru предоставляют шанс взять первый займ бесплатно.

    В наши дни подобрать сервис, который предоставляет шанс выбирать релевантные предложения невероятно тяжко. Последнее время достаточно много компаний, которые предоставляют подобные услуги, начали оформлять средства на короткий срок. Некоторые из таких компаний являются не надежными. Именно для того, чтобы потребители могли брать деньги без трудностей вне зависимости от ситуации, вы можете взять кредит на карту виртуально без отказа в любое время ночи.

    Сервис пользуется популярностью в связи с тем, что он постоянно проводит анализ компаний и специалисты следят за всеми изменениями на рынке. Именно это позволяет создать крутой рейтинг всех сервисов и солидных кредиторов. На сайте доступен список новых МФО 2018 года, где собраны самые надежные МФО. Большинство из компаний предоставляют срочный займ на карту без просмотра кредитной истории, что считается большим преимуществом в наше время.

    На https://mega-zaimer.ru/ вы можете найти компанию, которая будет выгодна именно вам. Портал очень простой и станет интересен для всех пользователей. Стоит выделить, что на портале вы подберете фирму по следующим критериям: сумма займа, срок ссуды, регион, метод получения финансов. Большинство мужчин желают брать виртуальные займы на карту, чтобы распоряжаться финансами.

    Сегодня любой человек может оформить займ и ему 100% одобрят его ссуду. Ведь сервис собрал самых честных кредиторов, которые считаются настоящими профессионалами. Специалисты сервиса постоянно отслеживают всю информацию по поводу работы МФО. Шанс получить займ есть даже у тех, у кого плохая кредитная история. Сервис будет полезным и по той причине, что он советуем компании, которые предоставляют средства в ночное время суток.

    Не так много компаний предоставляют займы в ночное время суток. Сейчас выбрать компанию, которая предоставит займ срочно без отказов и проверок на карту круглосуточно, да еще и в ночное время суток – практически невозможно. Однако, сервис предлагает перечень МФО, которые могут быть интересны вам.

    На финансовом портале mega-zaimer.ru потребители имеют возможность взять займы на карту вне зависимости от ситуации. Вам не нужно будет докладывать, как в банковское учреждение, куда будут идти финансы. За вашими транзакциями также не будут следить. Во всех МФО заявки обрабатываются очень быстро. Также стоит сказать, что для благополучных кредиторов действуют определенные предложения. Сервис также оснащен service desk, которая ответит на любые ваши вопросы при первой же потребности.

  • Many young girls worry about their vitality. Most girls also look after their body. It is very significant now to use podiatry services. With their assistance probable to solve inequable issues at legs. If you have some problems with nails, these services should also support you. If you want to utilize podiatry services, the best way to use them at podologijosklinika.lt, where working vocational specialists.

    Today at podologijosklinika.lt there are a lot of guys who treat various problems nagu protezavimas most specialists who suggest podiatry services are working in the different daytime. That is why you could visit Podologijos Klinika at the different time. At the company, there is a lot of moders equipment. With the suggest of podiatry probable to solve issues at legs like cracks in the skin. If you have any discomfort at your foots, better to go to podiatry clinic. It disposed in Antakalnio g. 40, Vilnius 10305. You could also call +37069999139 and ask different questions. Administrators who are working at the firm are real specialists and they will reply for different your questions.

    Today skin problems are the most important problems of health. With these problems can meet men and ladies. If you desire to eliminate skin issues, better to utilize services at the professional office. If you never been in the clinic but you have skin problems, you should have hyperkeratosis. Otherwise skin problems arise of the reason for bad hygiene. If you have nail inflammation, you can have onychocryptosis. This is a illness which connected with painful functions. Medics who are working at the clinic could support you. They will make complete inspectorate and suggest treatment services.

    One of the most significant problems with health may be a diabetic fool. It is a very rigid disease. Often it combined with problems of blood circulation. Physicians will suggest to solve problems with health. If you would not treat your sickness, it may suggest more discomfort. As rule, this kind of health problem is dangerously for folk of different age.

    If you have any problems with nail diseases, you should visit podologijosklinika.lt where specialists will help you. Actually, more and more people in European countries have various issues with their nails. If you wish to have nice nails, you must follow for your hygiene too.

    If you have matters like Hyperhidrosis (sweating feet), doctors can also solve this problem. This task necessary to treat. There are many reasons why this problem can appear. If you wish to solve it, better to call administrators. They will answer how possible to treat your legs and which tablets future to utilize. This organization located in the central part of the Vilnius and you can visit it in the daytime.

  • That is really interesting, You’re an excessively professional blogger.

    I’ve joined your rss feed and look ahead to in the hunt for extra of your
    magnificent post. Also, I’ve shared your web site in my social
    networks

  • A lot of guys today prefer to take loans. With their help possible to solve various economical problems. If you desire something to buy but you haven’t need sum, better to take payday loans in USA. At the moment payday loans in the United States of America are very prominent. More and more men in various states take loans and are very happy. If you demand a very fast money advance in USA, better to take in web. On maybeloan.com you may take virtual loans and be sure that they will provide for your coins.

    This organization is very popular and it has their private customer service. If you have a bad credit history, it is ok. You mustn’t worry about it. If you have not any credit check payday credits in USA, it is also not a problem. You could use quick payday loans in TX even you have the poor credit history in USA. Many people from various places take short-term loans in USA. It is a very in great request service nowadays and it is very great that the firm provide these.

    Different people are external in USA and they haven’t opportunity swift to take mortgages online. That is why for them there is a chance to use instant payday loans in USA. As rule, if you want payday loans in Arizona, you mustn’t go to the banking house. It is probable to use a website and get credits online. Even guys have a bad credit history, for them, these company suggest different options. Low credit payday credits in Arizona is not an issue challenge nowadays.

    At Colorado, more people at the job don’t get coins in a time. That is the reason for folk must take credits. If you don’t wish to go to the bank and to utilize bank loan, we also advised for you to use fast money advance in Colorado. It is probable to utilize this style of service because it is very famous nowadays and it will suggest you to obtain money on time. If you have children, money also need in time. That is why this selection is very popular in Colorado too. This model of serve is very popular and more and more men receive online loans today from Colorado.

    Even you don’t know, needful to combine with payday credits web in Minnesota, we advised to utilize this service and make sure that this type of service is very cozy. At maybeloan.com you could take varied loan types. So, if you desire to use coins payday loans in Minnesota, make a choice and use coins on the comfortable term. Any credits as well are issued for a durable period.

    If you need money for a big purchase, for example, a yacht or a flat, you should as well get a loan. Currently instant payday credits in Missouri are very well-known. It will support you to do a purchase and be lucky. If you don’t wish to pay «анкор» some fees, don’t use banking services. At MayBeloan you can use services without the fees. It is very cosily to receive a loan online. Necessary to do application form and than, you can utilize your private cash.

    More and more different organizations make the mechanism of provision of the fund like bank institution. That is why any folk thinking that better to use cash in the banking house. If you wish to obtain fast cash payday credits in Oregon, you should go on maybeloan.com where you can use their services. They have flexible payment options. They don’t check your own credit history. Even you have a bad credit history, it is not a task. They allow various amounts for various guys all over the country. Now they suggest solving the financial issue more than 1500 customers.

    If you desire to obtain money, you must do next steps. First of all, you need to apply the application form. Then you must to expect approved. After this, you may get cash and be happy. If you have some questions, you must ask customer service. This service is online 24/7, that is why they will help with varient choices. If you desire to obtain dollars fast, utilize this service. They will supply for your roads of permission of your issues.

  • Heya are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and set up my own. Do you need any coding knowledge to make your own blog? Any help would be really appreciated!

  • An impressive share! I have just forwarded this onto a friend who was
    conducting a little research on this. And he actually ordered me
    breakfast due to the fact that I found it for him…
    lol. So let me reword this…. Thank YOU for the meal!!
    But yeah, thanks for spending time to talk about this subject here on your internet site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *